Breaking News Aldon Smith Suspended 9 Games By NFL ×

Our Luck Just Ran Out! Now What?


Andrew Luck just said no to the Carolina Panthers.

Andrew Luck will remain at Stanford. Panthers fans are not happy.

It was just two weeks ago we were all ecstatic that our team held the number one overall pick in the 2011 NFL Draft.  Remember that?  Now…not so much.

Okay, Andrew, stay in school.  Get your degree.  Maybe we’ll have a shot at you next year.

Whatever happens those of us dreaming of taking the kid from Stanford will have to keep dreaming.

So where does this leave us?  We still hold that pick.  It’s ours.  What should the team do now?

One answer that will get thrown around is trading down.  But will it be that easy?  Consider that Luck had declared.  The pick would hold a lot more value to the other 32 teams.  Without him in the mix, the value has plummeted.  There could still be enough talent at the top of the draft board to entice a team to pull the trigger on a deal but it’s less likely now.

Let’s just go on the assumption that we keep the pick.  Who do we take?  Here are five options in no particular order.

Da’Quan Bowers – DE, Clemson

He started slow at the college level and the coaches put more pressure on him to produce this past season.  He did.  The kid was all over the place and became a finalist for the Lombardi Award, Bednarik Award and the Nagurski Award for 2010

He fits well into a 4-3 system and would work well opposite Charles Johnson but there’s a knock on him in that his leverage is, at times, rather weak.

Patrick Peterson – CB, LSU

He’s been touted for some time now and continued to prove himself again this season at LSU.  He racked up numerous honors in 2010 including:  Bedarik Award Winner (Nation’s top defender, Thorpe Award Winner (Top DB), Concesus All-American, First-Team All American (AP, AFCA Coaches, Walter Camp, Football Wroters Assoc. of America, CBSSports.com, Rivals.com, SI.com, CollegeFootballNews.com).

The kid at times had analysts comparing him to Derelle Revis.  With the likely departure of Richard Marshall, Peterson could be a good fit.

A.J. Green – WR, Georgia

The first knock on Green is his lack of bulk.  At 6’4″ and 205 some scouts would like to see him add some size.  But his leaping ability and soft hands make this kid stand out.

He’s got the tools to succeed at the next level though some wonder about his route running.

Green may be a last resort considering the team just invested so many picks in WR’s and the fact that development can be slow at this position.

Nick Fairly – DT, Auburn

This kid exploded onto the scene this season as he had spent 2008 in JUCO ball and had only 2 starts at Auburn in 2009.  But he was a major presence in the Tigers’ defense in 2010 and earned himself an awful lot of attention leading up to the draft.

At 6’5″ 298 he could be the answer in the middle of the Panthers defense – likely the weakest area of the team.  He could be a solid addition.

However, the knocks on him are that he doesn’t work terribly well against double teams and that his motor tends to run hot and cold.

Ryan Mallett – QB, Arkansas

Possessing a powerful arm, Mallett deserves some consideration.  AT 6’6″ 238 he has the size necessary at the next level.

Some scouts have been left scratching their heads at times after some of his passes wondering why he would make the throw leading some to wonder if he was in love with his arm strength.

He looks more and more like a boom or bust pick that could go either way.

Next Panthers Game View full schedule »
Dick's Sporting Goods presents "Hell Week":

Tags: AJ Green Andrew Luck Carolina Panthers Charles Johnson Da'Quan Bowers Nick Fairly Patrick Peterson Richard Marshall Ryan Mallett

  • Blkcats89

    Devestated by this news. I really belived we had our franchise qb. Now I think its best to trade the pick for a lower first rounder and draft an interior d-lineman.
    There is not a better qb in the 2011 draft than what we have on our roster now. We do have a real weakness in the middle of our d-line so it should be addressed with a draft pick or a player acquired in a trade for the 1st pick.

    • http://catcraveradio.com John White

      I lean toward Fairly but he could wind up being a poor man’s Suh an be a disappointment especially when taken with the first pick.

  • Easy A

    Any chance of trading our 1st round pic for a qb ??? I know hes past his prime but I would take McNabb I think he could fit in with our team and I think it would be an improvement

    • http://catcraveradio.com John White

      I would never trade the first overall pick unless I got a heckuva deal. McNabb is on his last legs an likely wouldn’t be around past two seasons at best. If we trade it would be for more draft picks.

  • lazyjay

    Our Luck Just Ran Out? I don’t know where you been these past months but our luck been ran out. The kid turns down 40 million dollars to go back to school. Which mean “I don’t want to get drafted by the panthers” I say we trade our number 1 pick for a player. Or gets some extra picks. Don’t get me wrong I still believe in matt Moore I think he’s a good QB just haven’t been coach the right way. We need to find some one to fill in the QB, DT, and DE position ASAP.

  • mcap

    It felt like my heart had been ripped out…. I just knew that we had finally found our franchise QB,and then I read in the sports page that he wants to stay in college. I am thinking that we should trade the pick for lower spots…. and hope that we again have the worst record next year….. Andrew can only dodge us but so long