Carolina Panthers: Evaluating the Quarterbacks

Not as scheduled (unfortunately we hit a glitch somewhere that delayed this post–my profound apologies), today we will take a look at the quarterback position on the Carolina Panthers.

Understandably, the quarterback position was a hot topic in 2009.

Going into the 2009 offseason, longtime starter Jake Delhomme arguably turned in the worst performance of his career, in probably the most meaningful game of his career, against the Arizona Cardinals in the playoffs.

Here I am still referencing that game, and neither the Panthers nor the Cardinals are in the playoffs at this point a year later.

But Delhomme is still a quarterback with the Panthers. To what extent we do not know at this time. Going into the 2010 camps and preseason, I’d like to see a competitive and very open competition between Delhomme and Matt Moore, and give Hunter Cantwell some time as well. This team needs a reliable No. 2 QB if Delhomme is not “the man” for that position, either.

At this point in time, the team will have five quarterbacks on the roster: Jake Delhomme, Matt Moore, A.J. Feeley, Hunter Cantwell, and Josh McCown.

Since John Fox will remain the head coach for 2010, I don’t see Feeley staying beyond the one-year contract he signed with the Panthers. In fact, I wouldn’t be surprised to see him back with the Philadelphia Eagles come springtime. Reason being, Fox has been a backer of McCown for a number of years.

So looking into the future, we can most likely be assured that the Panthers will retain everyone but Feeley. Which I feel to be a mistake, because I know Feeley has proven himself and his body of work speaks for itself. If it were my choice to be made, I’d look to keep Feeley for a couple years and move on without either Delhomme or McCown.

Since Delhomme is under contract for two more years, the realistic option would be to trade or dump McCown. I don’t see either happening.

I don’t feel very confident that the Panthers will make drafting a quarterback a high priority. I feel strongly that the competition will be kept between Moore and Delhomme, and should Moore win the starting job (I hope he does)–after seeing his duress under pressure and not letting defenses rattle his brain–I know he can lead this team into the playoffs.

A position the team should consider drafting for in the second round, would be wide receiver. But who should they draft?

Looking at mock drafts–mind you I’m not putting all my eggs in one basket there, either–Notre Dame’s Golden Tate looks to fall into the second-round, based primarily on his 40-yard time. If it’s a high time, he’s projected to fall to the second round. If not, then he could very well be gone by the time the Panthers get around to making their first selection of the draft.

I digress, the wide receiver analysis and draft day needs will be addressed at a later date.

A new rumor circulating around Philadelphia, is that the Eagles could be looking to trade one or two of it’s quarterbacks. Donovan McNabb has been mentioned; Kevin Kolb and Michael Vick are also names in the mill.

Might any of these quarterbacks be of potential interest to the Panthers? If any of them, I would say Vick or McNabb.

Kevin Kolb is a young quarterback, close in age to Matt Moore. I don’t see the Panthers going for another quarterback who essentially brings the same element to the field that they already have in Moore.

McNabb could be of interest, because he would have one special weapon here in Carolina that he’s never had in Philadelphia…DeSean Jackson and Jeremy Maclin combined, do not equal one Steve Smith. The Panthers also have an offensive line unlike Philadelphia’s, and a very field-able tight end corps. McNabb would not be looked at as long-term potential in Carolina, so I doubt the Panthers would have much if any interest in him.

As for Michael Vick–personal history aside–he could bring a fourth dimension to the Panthers’ offense. Carolina has never had a quarterback who could lineup as such and have the elusive ability to run the ball himself. Vick has also shown that his passing mechanics can be honed some more and he could become a little more accurate of a passer.

Something McNabb and Vick can do as well–they both have the ability to move the pocket and are both fairly accurate passers on the run.

At any rate, I do feel fairly confident in the personnel at the quarterback position at this time, at least for Matt Moore, whom I would love to see earn the right to take over the starting job.

No, he hasn’t earned the right to assume that role yet, but he did clearly prove why he deserves the chance to claim the right in his five starts for the Panthers to end the season.

He had very strong performances, he was involved in only one loss (at the New England Patriots), he makes smart decisions, he doesn’t get rattled easily, he threw only one or two interceptions in five games, and against teams that usually have very good defenses.

The Minnesota Vikings were rated with a strong defense, the Patriots have always had a formidable defense, and even though the New Orleans Saints were resting most of their starting players, Moore didn’t have the luxury of throwing to Steve Smith. Who did he throw one touchdown pass to? wide receiver Dwayne Jarrett.

In the end, I’d like to see more time under center for Josh McCown and Hunter Cantwell. It would be nice to keep either of these guys, or maybe see Cantwell get moved into the lineup on gameday.

I don’t see very much if anything changing at the quarterback position this year. Possibly next year, but the Panthers won’t have Tim Tebow or Notre Dame’s Jimmy Clausen on it’s roster come April.

Check-in daily for Panthers’ news, rumors, and updates! Check back Wednesday morning when we will look at the offensive line(up).

Dick's Sporting Goods presents "Hell Week":

Tags: A J Feeley Arizona Cardinals Carolina Panthers DeSean Jackson Donovan McNabb Dwayne Jarrett Golden Tate Hunter Cantwell Jake Delhomme Jeremy Maclin Jimmy Clausen John Fox Josh McCown Kevin Kolb Matt Moore Michael Vick Minnesota Vikings New England Patriots New Orleans Saints News NFL Notre Dame Offensive Line Philadelphia Eagles Quarterback Rumors Steve Smith Tim Tebow Updates

  • Panthers Fan

    Imagine the running attack with Vick at QB and Stewart/Williams at RB. That would be like 300 rushing yards per game. And all Vick has to do is basically play the Wildcat QB an throw 15 times per game, 12 to Steve Smith.

    • Eric Quackenbush

      That would be an amazing ground game, for sure. You never know what might happen, but I would be a little surprised if the Panthers made a move to get Vick from the Eagles.

  • ChazAtlas

    I agree, there needs to be a genuine competition between Delhomme and Moore for the starting position. There seemed to be enough good chemistry with Moore and to warrant a serious competition. I would really like to know why Jake has been floating so many balls as of late. Is it the Tommy John surgery or is it mental?

    What either Jake or Matt needs is an experienced, tall receiver/blocker, 2nd go to guy opposite Steve Smith. It’s is unclear is Mushin Muhammed is coming back and Dwayne Jarrett has had glimpses of success but is inconsistent. A Terrell Owens or Derrick Mason (Ravens) could fit that bill. I don’t think Carolina could lose with putting Michael Vick on the roster. I am sure he could be had for a respectable salary that wouldn’t break the bank. Carolina would probably make his contract back in ticket & Vick t-shirt sales.

    • Eric Quackenbush

      Thanks for the read and comment, Chaz…

      I have no doubt there will be a serious and open competition between Moore and Delhomme this year. I don’t have a problem keeping Jake for another year–maybe two–as a backup (kinda stuck with him right now, lol. I really don’t know what Jake’s hangup is, though I tend to feel that it’s more mental than physical.

      Michael Vick on the roster, as I’ve said, will give the Panthers a fourth dimension to their offensive game plan. I don’t have a problem with his presence being in the backfield, and he’s still young enough.

      As for the receiver position (which I will address in the coming editions, I’d say the team will see what comes about in free agency or if they can make a trade for someone like Brandon Marshall Nate Burleson. Then they’ll decide whether they need to think about keeping Moose for another year or not. Muhammad has said he’d like to come back, but he wants more $, so whatever looks better financially AND for a longterm/promising player, I’m sure the Panthers will be on top of it.

  • frank

    Dude are you serious? DeSean Jackson and Jeremy Maclin don’t add up to one Steve Smith. Take your Panther blinders off. Philly has a solid o-line too, just depleted with injuries this year. Their line will be back next year. Look. I started to read this thinking it would be informative, and wanted to catch some possible McNabb trade rumors and it was someone pumping up his favorite team. Steve Smith is old, I would take him and something else thrown in for either Maclin or Jackson. Watch some other teams and then maybe you’ll get some pespective, also, you guys will never run for 300 yards a game are you kidding me.

    • Eric Quackenbush

      Thanks for the read and comment, Frank. You must have missed my points, but that’s okay.

      I didn’t say I wanted to trade Steve Smith, but that McNabb has never had the opportunity (owens catastrophe aside) of playing with a great receiver.

      I do have a good perspective on what’s going on outside of the Panthers, but thank you for your critique, anyway.

      As for the latest McNabb trade rumors, Arizona and Minnesota are said to be interested suitors.

      Thanks again Frank!

  • sonny casapulla

    I hope you are kidding when you say Jackson and Maclin don’t equal one Smith.I beliieve Jackson is a pro bowl starter and Maclin had a very fine rookie year. And your tight end corps? Rosario and King??? Put their numbers together and they still don’t better Celek.

    • Eric Quackenbush

      You forgot about Gary Barnidge, too, Sonny.

      Thanks for half-reading and the comment! Also, it’s listed under “OPINION.” Try not to take an opinion piece too seriously.

  • Mark Duckworth

    I would wager that the Super Bowl was a little more meaningful than a home playoff game..

    • Eric Quackenbush

      I would have to agree with you, Mark…Winning the Super Bowl is even bigger and more meaningful than just being there, though…That’s the ultimate goal.

      Thanks for reading and the interesting comment!

  • Force Factor

    Time for an quick Mardi Gras located in Miami. The colts have the knowledge, however the Saints have a better quality offense than anything the colts have encountered in a very long time. The Saints defense has moreover picked it up a step. Manning is a really great quarterback but even he is usually flustered when you smack him often enough. I can’t wait to see New Orleans having a Lombardi Trophy!

  • Florencio Zettler

    I can’t wait for this game! The saints should really have the capacity to put up a bunch of points on the colts. New Orleans absolutely seems to be a team of desitiny. The defense has surely stepped it up during the post season. There aren’t many doubts concerning the offense. Time to bring the Lombardi Trophy to the Big Easy!

    • Eric Quackenbush

      Should be a very good game on both sides…Why did you post in the Panthers’ Quarterbacks thread, though? Thank you for reading and commenting.

  • Pingback: Carolina Panthers: Evaluating the Quarterbacks | Cat Crave | A … | NFL Topics Blog