Skip to main content

Grading Bryce Young's performance as Panthers grind out vital Saints win

Bryce Young wasn't at his best, but it was just enough.
ByDean Jones
Carolina Panthers quarterback Bryce Young
Carolina Panthers quarterback Bryce Young | IMAGN IMAGES via Reuters Connect

The Carolina Panthers had to end their three-game skid against the New Orleans Saints. They got the job done, but it was far from a virtuoso performance.

That was true of quarterback Bryce Young, too.

After a sensational start to the season that put him in the early NFL MVP conversation, Young's play has tailed off in recent weeks. Other mitigating factors are in play, and maintaining his numbers before the bye was always going to be difficult. But if the Panthers want to retain the NFC South this season, they need more.

Bryce Young played the percentages to help Carolina Panthers win

The Saints made things difficult for Young. Their primary focus was taking away the stud wide receiver tandem of Tetairoa McMillan and Jalen Coker, and they did it well. This forced the signal-caller to adjust, but it was relatively mundane throughout the contest.

Young is a rhythm quarterback. When he gets into his groove early, the confidence visibly oozes from him.

But with more experience, the former Alabama standout is adapting well to what defenses throw at him.

The Saints played the percentages. They knew keeping McMillan and Coker quiet would help them. And with wide receiver Xavier Legette playing just two snaps after returning from a knee injury, the Panthers didn't have anyone who could consistently stretch the field.

Young had to work underneath. There was a lot of dinking and dunking to his tight ends and running back Chuba Hubbard, who carried the team offensively. It's not the most exciting way to move the chains, but it was just enough for the Panthers to prosper.

As for Young? He navigated the pocket well. Nothing overly spectacular about his performance, but he protected the football. And when the No. 1 pick in 2023 needed to make a big play, he came through.

Carolina Panthers beat the Saints, but Bryce Young has to be better

The play sequencing and overall game plan from offensive coordinator Brad Idzik weren't great, which restricted Young. There didn't seem to be many adjustments to what the Saints were throwing at them, and pressure came off the blindside too often.

There is an awful lot to clean up, but the result was easily the most important thing.

Young could have played better. There were some wayward throws and a couple of crucial drops. Nothing looked in sync offensively aside from Hubbard, whose 172 yards from scrimmage tipped the scales in Carolina's favor.

But a win is a win. And they all count the same.

There are some timing issues to work on. Young needs to get back on the same page with his receivers, especially Coker. Idzik must do his part by scheming things more effectively, perhaps using more motions and misdirections to keep opposing defenses off balance.

However, Young must also have the freedom to be creative out of structure.

The Saints didn't give him that chance, and the Panthers' offense stuttered. Fortunately, Tyler Shough was much worse, and that was all the Panthers needed for a priceless victory.

This keeps Carolina atop the NFC South. But with a sturdy Baltimore Ravens defense looking to bounce back from an embarrassing prime-time loss to the previously winless Los Angeles Chargers up next, Young must be more clinical.

That's the long and short of it, really.

Bryce Young performance grade: C+

Add us as a preferred source on Google