Winner No. 2
Jaelan Phillips - Carolina Panthers OLB
The Carolina Panthers got edge rusher Jaelan Phillips back at the best possible time. His presence was desperately needed, and the big-money free-agent signing picked up where he left off.
Phillips showed no ill effects from his hamstring injury. He was terrorizing the New Orleans Saints' reshuffled offensive line, getting into the backfield consistently in all phases.
Whether it was leaving his mark against the run or generating pressure on Saints quarterback Tyler Shough, Phillips did it all. This was a complete performance from Carolina's $120 million man, proving precisely why general manager Dan Morgan spent such lavish sums to secure his services.
The 2021 first-round pick out of Miami had five tackles, one sack, three tackles for loss, two quarterback hits, and a fumble recovery. Phillips was a relentless force from start to finish, and if he can keep this up over the next eight games, the Panthers will be in pretty good shape.
Loser No. 2
Carolina Panthers' discipline
The Panthers are the NFL's most penalized team. Whether fans agree with some calls is moot; this is a big problem head coach Dave Canales hasn't quite solved yet.
Things got even worse against the Saints. Carolina was flagged for an astonishing 17 penalties throughout the contest, conceding 152 yards. In contrast, the Saints had three infringements totaling 46 yards.
Some of the penalties were questionable at best. But either way, this is completely unacceptable. And the Panthers were incredibly lucky that it didn't cost them the win.
Canales acknowledged that discipline must be better. The false starts and jumping offsides on defense are avoidable mistakes. Crying about the officials would be fine if this was just a one-game blip, but it's been going on all season.
With the margins finer than ever for the Panthers within a very winnable NFC South, they have to clean up their act and take these decisions out of the refs' hands. They cannot keep shooting themselves in the foot like this. It's that simple.
Winner No. 3
Tommy Tremble - Carolina Panthers TE
Tommy Tremble is enjoying a new lease of life this season. The veteran tight end has some added urgency in a contract year, and he looks well on course to earn a third contract with the Panthers after a sensational start to 2026.
The improved confidence is oozing from Tremble. He has emerged into one of the league's most accomplished and violent tight ends. That was always his calling card, but this time there's more trust in his abilities as a pass-catcher.
In a game where downfield shots were at a premium, quarterback Bryce Young had to rely on short completions. Getting the ball into his playmakers' hands to earn yards after the catch was the only viable option, and Tremble was a big part of that.
With four receptions on five targets for 48 receiving yards, Tremble delivered another outstanding all-around performance. And he is now an integral part of Carolina's offensive strategy.
