Skip to main content

Panthers film review shows how Carolina survived 17 penalties to beat Saints

It wasn't pretty, but there were some positives.
ByJared Feinberg
Carolina Panthers offensive coordinator Brad Idzik
Carolina Panthers offensive coordinator Brad Idzik | IMAGN IMAGES via Reuters Connect

The Carolina Panthers are in sole possession of first place in the NFC South after their big walk-off win against the New Orleans Saints.

But after a closer look at the game film, there was a lot to unpack.

As the franchise heads home for its Week 11 matchup with the Baltimore Ravens, there is still much to discuss from this past weekend's game. It wasn't the prettiest, but several key players and one side of the ball played exceptionally well to secure the win.

I took some time to work through the film to dissect what occurred in New Orleans. Here are the notes from my film review of the Panthers' triumph against the Saints.

Carolina Panthers film review shows the good and bad from Saints win

Chuba Hubbard's terrific day

The Panthers' sixth-year running back hit the double whammy, leading the team with 172 total yards, including a team-best 92 rushing yards and 80 receiving yards. It still amazes me that fans wanted to trade Chuba Hubbard after he lost his starting spot to Rico Dowdle, but the Oklahoma State product has shown why he remains a core piece of the roster.

Hubbard is a workhorse weapon who is playing the best football of his career. He showcases reliable hands as a receiver and offers good vision and balance to find hidden yards before and after contact. He displays some smooth cutbacks and did a good job pressing the line of scrimmage to find creases to exploit.

Color me impressed once again, as Hubbard continues to be the engine of the Panthers' offense while the rest of the perimeter pass-catchers go through a slump.

Brad Idzik, we need a chat

We're seeing, as of late, that offensive coordinator Brad Idzik is far from ready to be a head-coaching candidate.

Sunday's game was a masterclass in improper play sequencing, poor decision-making in specific down-and-distance situations, and putting your offense at a disadvantage through your own doing.

Idzik has been going hard on attacking the intermediate and deep portions of the field, which has shown positive results until a smart defensive coordinator such as Brandon Staley figures it out.

The first-year play-caller must do a better job of putting his struggling receivers, Tetairoa McMillan and Jalen Coker, in better spots to succeed. Specifically, he needs to increase usage in the short areas of the field, where Idzik can use spacing concepts that allow quarterback Bryce Young to pick and choose which side of the field to attack based on the pre- and post-snap picture.

The lack of production and usage from Xavier Legette hasn't helped, as his vertical element is missing from this offense. However, it is up to Idzik to better position his offense for success and protect not just his quarterback but also the struggling offensive line.

Todd Wash's defense shines

Carolina's interim defensive coordinator is beginning to prove that head coach Dave Canales' decision to fire Ejiro Evero was the right one. The Panthers have once again played outstanding run defense for the third week in a row, thanks to Todd Wash's one-gap attacking principles.

With these principles, the edge rushers are more aggressive upfield, and defensive linemen play more penetration and crash techniques. A key change we saw in this game? Rookie Zakee Wheatley becoming the starting free safety in single-high alignments.

Wheatley looked great at free safety, handling single-high deep zone responsibilities well. He remained a great open-field tackler and had two strong man-coverage reps, including a jam on rookie wide receiver Jordyn Tyson on a corner route in the first quarter.

Defensive front seven led the way

This one-gap scheme is also letting fans see what Tershawn Wharton can do as both a pass rusher and run defender, and he has become an important piece of the defense since his return. Rookie Lee Hunter, despite playing 15 snaps, was consistently in the backfield, as was star defensive lineman Derrick Brown, who tallied his first sack of the season.

Star edge rusher Jaelan Phillips returned from a hamstring injury this week and looked like the man the Panthers paid $120 million for, tallying eight pressures and two sacks (we're counting the "horsecollar" tackle).

I loved Phillips' frequent use of an inside swim and dip-rip to stress both the inside and outside shoulder of the offensive tackle. He was stout as an edge rusher and seemed to overwhelm the Saints' tight ends in the run game with his long arms and powerful upper half, penetrating the backfield almost at will.

Add us as a preferred source on Google