Skip to main content

Brandon Aiyuk could test how far the Panthers will go to fix their offense

It makes more sense than you'd think.
ByDean Jones
San Francisco 49ers wide receiver Brandon Aiyuk
San Francisco 49ers wide receiver Brandon Aiyuk | USA TODAY Sports via Reuters Connect

The Carolina Panthers' passing attack has tailed off in recent weeks after a sensational start to the season. It's not clicking as teams begin to figure out offensive coordinator Brad Idzik's scheme, and the first-time play-caller has not made the right adjustments yet.

The Panthers have Xavier Legette back, which should help open up the field. But with so much at stake for Carolina over its remaining eight games, general manager Dan Morgan may want to think outside the box.

And with Brandon Aiyuk's departure from the San Francisco 49ers seemingly imminent, it could provoke a discussion in Carolina's front office.

Brandon Aiyuk's imminent release could be a risk worth taking for Carolina Panthers

Aiyuk gained headlines for all the wrong reasons this summer, taking shots at everyone on social media and practically begging to join the Washington Commanders. This irked the Niners, to put it mildly, and the wideout grew frustrated as his league aspirations fell flat.

The NFL had seemingly cast him aside. San Francisco wanted nothing to do with him.

But fortunately for Aiyuk, he saw the error of his ways.

The Arizona State product hired Drew Rosenhaus to be his agent. Aiyuk immediately applied for reinstatement, which was granted after passing a physical. Discussions have taken place with the Niners, but none of them have involved potentially returning to the setup.

All signs point to a breakup once a financial compromise is reached. The Niners have until Monday to either activate or release Aiyuk. It doesn't take a genius to figure out how that will go, and attention will then turn to his next destination.

The Commanders remain heavily rumored, especially as Aiyuk and quarterback Jayden Daniels have reportedly patched things up. Other suitors will no doubt show their hand, and perhaps it might be worth the Panthers investigating this possibility in greater detail.

Carolina Panthers would need to overlook Brandon Aiyuk's character concerns and injury history

It's highly unlikely, of course. But if Aiyuk can get back to anything like his old form, this is a risk well worth taking.

Whether he can or not is another matter.

Aiyuk hasn't played since a serious knee injury suffered midway through the 2024 campaign. That's a lot of football missed, so his best chance is signing to a practice squad somewhere and building himself up gradually.

Obviously, there are also character concerns. Aiyukl may not be the best fit for Carolina's locker room in that regard, but if Rosenhaus' silver tongue makes people think twice about overlooking this questionable part of his character, it wouldn't cost the Panthers much to find out one way or another.

It's a long shot, of course. The Panthers might be content to roll with what they have and hope things improve. But if Morgan wants to be a little bolder, there isn't a higher upside player than Aiyuk if he toes the line and finally stays healthy.

The chances are remote, honestly. But it wouldn't hurt to put in a call once Aiyuk's messy divorce from San Francisco is finally confirmed.

Watch this space...

Add us as a preferred source on Google