Skip to main content

Panthers may have to put special teams ahead of Jonathon Brooks

The Carolina Panthers may not get their second-round running back from injured reserve for another week.
ByJared Feinberg
Carolina Panthers running back Jonathon Brooks
Carolina Panthers running back Jonathon Brooks | IMAGN IMAGES via Reuters Connect

The Carolina Panthers are getting healthier, and it couldn't have come at a better time.

This week, Carolina will get cornerbacks Mike Jackson Sr. and Will Lee III back from their respective injuries after they missed time. Offensive lineman Brady Christensen may return as well, while edge rusher Jaelan Phillips won NFC Defensive Player of the Week coming off a three-week absence from a hamstring injury.

However, a curious story has emerged with oft-injured running back Jonathon Brooks, who is attempting to make his return from groin surgery. The numbers aren't adding up, and it could leave him out for another week.

The numbers are not aligning for the Carolina Panthers to activate Jonathon Brooks

On Friday, head coach Dave Canales spoke to reporters before Sunday's home game against the struggling Baltimore Ravens. When asked about Brooks' availability, Canales comments were intriguing, to say the least.

"[Brooks has done a great job working back to make himself available. And as he continues to attack it, he had some really aggressive runs this week. And so [general manager] Dan [Morgan] and I have to have those conversations. How do we get Jonathon up for game day when we know were giving the ball to Chuba [Hubbard]? Trevor [Etienne] does so much for us in the return game. Tre Tyus is playing on three phases in special teams and I wouldn't be mad about giving Tre the ball, in different situations if it came up, too."

This is a fascinating situation for the Panthers, but it is much simpler than it is made out to be.

Obviously, everyone wants to see Brooks on the field and playing good football, which fans haven't seen since his days at Texas. He has spent the majority of his NFL career in rehab from two consecutive torn ACLs and, most recently, groin surgery that landed him on injured reserve after Week 2.

However, the Panthers are getting terrific play from running back Chuba Hubbard, who has been more or less the engine of the offense for the last handful of weeks. He is coming off a career game against the New Orleans Saints, and there is no reason why the Panthers shouldn't give him the ball.

As the saying goes, don't fix what isn't broken.

Here is where the math gets tricky for Brooks in Week 11.

The Panthers are without three of their five best special teams players. Thomas Incoom, Akayleb Evans, and Isaiah Simmons are missing, which means other players on the roster have to fill in some significant roles.

Jonathon Brooks may have to wait another week, and that's fine

This leads to, as Canales mentioned, the conversations with Morgan about roster dynamics: who comes up and who stays down for this weekend? Jackson is already slated to play, with Christensen in the mix.

However, with Trevor Etienne being the Panthers' best return specialist, Tre Tyus becoming a key special teams player in recent weeks, and no plans to ease Hubbard's workload, waiting another week for Brooks to be activated from injured reserve isn't the worst idea. And it by no means says they are already giving up on the third-year tailback.

The Panthers simply need to see what they have this week and will evaluate everything else next week ahead of a pivotal primetime NFC South matchup with the Tampa Bay Buccaneers.

Brooks is still in the plans for Carolina in this final stretch. He doesn't provide much special teams value and would only be serving as a backup to Hubbard, as the fourth-round standout from Oklahoma State continues to get significant touches.

However, when the Panthers feel they can ease Hubbard's workload, that is when Brooks can step in.

In all, it is fairly simple for why Brooks may not play this week, and it is something fans shouldn't fret over in the immediate.

Add us as a preferred source on Google