Skip to main content

Brian Thomas Jr.’s benching could tempt Panthers to break Dan Morgan’s trade mold

This would be a surprising move.
ByJared Feinberg
Jacksonville Jaguars wide receiver Brian Thomas Jr.
Jacksonville Jaguars wide receiver Brian Thomas Jr. | USA TODAY Network via Reuters Connect

In the three seasons general manager Dan Morgan has been in charge of building the Carolina Panthers, he hasn't made a move his predecessor would have.

Aggressive moves and/or trades have seemingly become a thing of the past for the Panthers as they continue building a roster into a contending franchise. However, as Carolina's offense continues to put up big numbers, it is hard not to be intrigued by the ceiling it could have in 2026.

Jacksonville Jaguars wide receiver Brian Thomas Jr. could help them reach that ceiling and more. It is an aggressive, splashy move that would potentially shock many in the NFL.

Brian Thomas Jr. could bring endless passing game opportunities for the Carolina Panthers

It is a move that some would be surprised by, considering Morgan's lack of aggression in the trade market. He is far from what Scott Fitterer was, arguably more disciplined and decisive in his approach.

However, the Jaguars seemed to signal the end of Thomas' tenure after benching him in the second half against the Houston Texans in London.

Two years ago, Thomas looked like a future star in Jacksonville after catching 87 passes for 1,282 receiving yards and 10 touchdowns as a rookie.

Now, he needs a change of scenery that could benefit all parties.

Thomas is immensely gifted with vertical speed and the ability to split defenders. He can run the full route tree and provide a level of explosiveness the Panthers don't have right now, despite having one of the best offenses in the NFL through six weeks.

The idea of pairing Thomas with quarterback Bryce Young, star wide receiver Tetairoa McMillan, and Jalen Coker would certainly feel like Christmas or Hanukkah came early this year.

Carolina Panthers could make a high-risk, high-reward move for Brian Thomas Jr.

It would open up the vertical passing game like we haven't seen since Ted Ginn Jr. was with the franchise in the mid-2010s.

Yet, there is risk involved in all of this.

While Thomas may be a gifted player, it would come at a cost.

I have no doubt Morgan would consider adding the third-year wideout to the roster, but it could take some convincing of head coach Dave Canales to pull the trigger. It would also require conviction and alignment on all fronts.

The cost for Thomas would likely involve a Day 2 selection from the upcoming NFL Draft, though it might be lower than what the Arizona Cardinals got for Marvin Harrison Jr. A lot of fans would feel uneasy about that. That may also be true of Morgan and Canales, who have shown they value their draft capital highly.

Inconsistencies have plagued Thomas since last season, whether it be drops, not handling contact in space, or moments of lackadaisical effort. Does some of that sound familiar?

Xavier Legette has dealt with the same issues and is currently on injured reserve with a knee injury. If Thomas is moved, Legette's role would continue to diminish and signal the end of that partnership.

The Panthers also drafted Chris Brazzell II in the third round this past spring before he tore his LCL in training camp. He still looks to be in the team's long-term plans as their downfield threat. You can never have too many good wide receivers, though.

It feels as though key top wide receivers from the 2024 NFL Draft need new places to refocus and re-establish their footing in the league. This also includes Thomas, and Jacksonville could soon signal it's open for business with the former LSU standout.

Overall, a move for Thomas has its benefits and flaws.

Someone could pull the trigger on an offer for the talented pass-catcher, and it could be Carolina.

Add us as a preferred source on Google